Rating sources vary by brand. Googan shows an on-site rating; FishVault & 6th Sense do not list a clear star rating.
Verified reviews
Anglers love their box
Recent buyers mention convenience, variety, usable tackle, and the monthly surprise.
Happiness
“It’s like Christmas every month. It saves me a trip to the store and I’ve caught lots of fish using what they sent.”
Read full review +
I love it when my box comes in. It’s like Christmas every month. It’s convenient because it saves me a trip to the store — more time on the water fishing. Love the wide variety of lures and gear. I’ve caught lots of fish using just what they sent me. It’s worth it and I love my box.
JJosh Preite05/27/2026Verified
Ultimate lures
“I’ve been a loyal customer for 5 months and was never disappointed.”
Read full review +
I’ve been a loyal customer for 5 months and was never disappointed — mainly got the inland saltwater box for striper. Never a disappointment.
JJoe from Norcal05/27/2026Verified
Fun surprise!
“Very exciting to receive lures for the time and area I live in. I’ve been very pleased so far.”
Read full review +
Very exciting to receive lures for the time and area I live in. I just received my second box and can’t wait for my 3rd! Good luck and happy fishing!
CCfarm06/11/2026Verified
Always something different
“The last box had several styles of lures I always use, plus a unique plastic worm I’m excited to try.”
Read full review +
Very satisfied with the decision to subscribe. The last box had several styles of lures I always use, top water and a very unique plastic worm I’m excited to try. And the empty boxes make great excess tackle storage.
KKevin Hendrix06/18/2026Verified
Value for your money
“After 3 months I find it well worth the price. I’ve used everything so far.”
Read full review +
I was tentative about trying this, but after 3 months I find it well worth the price. I expected some cheap stuff but most of it is usable — I’ve used everything so far.
BBobby Phillips06/18/2026Verified
Love it!
“A wonderful way to get different ways to catch the fish I plan on catching.”
Read full review +
Such a wonderful subscription service to get different ways to catch the fish I plan on catching. The baits work with the tackle I already have, so there’s something new to try on my fishing trips.
TTristan06/20/2026Verified
Choose your box
Pick your plan
Most affordable
Regular
$19.99/mo+
Lowest way into a monthly box.
4–6 baits / month
5 species to choose
Pause or cancel anytime
Choose your species:
Most popular
Pro
$31.99/mo+
Best balance of tackle, value & discovery.
6–8 baits / month
6 species to choose
Bigger monthly unboxing
Choose your species:
Best value
Elite
$44.99/mo+
The most tackle, every month.
8–10 baits / month
3 premium species
Highest box value
Choose your species:
Free shipping on every multi-month plan · Pause, cancel or change species anytime
FAQs
Before you choose
Everything you need to know before your first box.
What comes in a monthly box?
Every Mystery Tackle Box is packed with premium fishing tackle selected for your target species and the current season. Depending on your plan, you'll receive:
Regular: 4–6 baits and tackle items (typically $25+ value)
Pro: 6–8 premium baits and tackle items (typically $40+ value)
Elite: 8–10 premium baits and tackle items (typically $60+ value)
You'll also receive expert tips and educational content to help you fish every lure with confidence, so you're not just getting tackle—you're becoming a better angler.
What's the difference between Regular, Pro, and Elite?
The biggest differences are the number of baits, the quality of the assortment, and the overall value.
Regular is perfect for newer anglers or anyone looking for incredible value with 5–6 proven lures.
Pro adds more premium baits and technique-specific tackle for anglers looking to expand their arsenal.
Elite is our top-tier experience, featuring 8–10 premium products, higher-end brands, and our best overall value.
No matter which plan you choose, every box is curated by anglers who know what catches fish.
Will I get tackle I actually use?
Absolutely. Your box is customized based on the species you fish, and every month's selection is curated around seasonal patterns and proven techniques—not random leftovers.
Fish bass this month and want to chase trout next month? No problem. You can switch your target species anytime from your account, and we'll build your next box accordingly.
Can I pause or cancel?
Yes. You're always in control. You can manage your subscription online, switch species, update your plan, or cancel whenever you need.
And if you ever run into an issue, our friendly U.S.-based customer service team is here to help. Whether it's a shipping question, account change, or anything else, we'll work with you to make it right.
Is it a good gift?
It's one of our most popular gifts for anglers of every experience level. Instead of another gift card or gadget, they'll receive a surprise box of premium fishing tackle delivered every month—keeping the excitement going long after the holidays or birthday.
Gift subscriptions are easy to purchase, available in multiple plan lengths, and let the recipient choose the species they fish, making it a gift they'll actually use on the water.
Your first box is a cast away
Curated tackle, flexible plans, delivered monthly — from $19.99.
Choose species
Pick plan
Get tackle monthly
MTB vs MonsterbassBass-only challenger
+–
MTB vs Lucky Tackle BoxSimilar price, different proof
+–
MTB vs Googan SquadSingle-brand box
+–
MTB vs FishVaultPremium, high-budget box
+–
MTB vs 6th Sense BaitboxSingle-brand fan box
+–
