Need help choosing?
Not sure which box? We got you
Tell us how you fish and we'll point you to the right box based on your target species and fishery.
Find my box →Compare Fishing Subscription Boxes Before You Buy
Some boxes are built for bass-only anglers. Some are built for fans of one brand. Some cost a small boat payment.
MTB is built for anglers of all abilities: affordable, flexible, giftable & easy-to-start.
to start
fish what you chase
no tackle box needed
pause or cancel anytime
Need help choosing?
Tell us how you fish and we'll point you to the right box based on your target species and fishery.
A Comparison of Price, Ratings, & Features
Everything you need to size up the field before you pick.
|
Compare the field 6 boxes · one view |
Mystery Tackle Box Best all-around |  Monsterbass
| 
Lucky Tackle Box
| 
Googan Squad
| 
FishVault
| 
6th Sense Baitbox
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| What you get | ||||||
| Items per box | 4 – 10 | 6 – 7 | 5 – 9+ | 6 – 8 | Premium | Varies |
| Multi-brand variety | Googan only | Mixed gear | 6th Sense only | |||
| Number of species | 6 | 1 | 3 | 1 | 1 | 1 |
| Can you switch species? | – | – | – | – | – | |
| Trust & track record | ||||||
| Customer rating | 3.8★ Trustpilot | 2.6★ Trustpilot | 2.8★ Trustpilot | 4.6★ On-site | Not listed | Not listed |
| Number of reviews | 7,565 Trustpilot | 64 Trustpilot | 2,840 Trustpilot | 83 On-site | Not listed | Not listed |
| Years in business | 14 | 7 | 13 | 8 | 6 | 6 |
| Boxes sold | 10M+ | Thousands | 50K | Not listed | Not listed | Not listed |
| Extras | ||||||
| Tips & tricks content | Limited | Limited | Limited | |||
| Rewards program | – | – | – | – | ||
| Digital perks partnership | – | – | – | – | – | |
| Pricing & fit | ||||||
| Best for | Most anglers | Bass-only anglers | Tutorials | Googan fans | High budget | 6th Sense fans |
| Starting at | $19.99+ | $28.95+ | $19.99+ | $34.99 | $160 | $49.99+ |
Lowest start
MTB at $19.99+Most premium
FishVault at $160Rating sources vary by brand. Trustpilot ratings are company-level public reviews; Googan and 6th Sense show ratings on product or brand pages; FishVault does not list a clear star rating on its own site.
Best all-around pick
Mystery Tackle Box
Lowest entry price among the mainstream options
Clear Regular, Pro, and Elite plan ladder
Bass, Panfish & Trout, Inshore Salt, Walleye & Multi-Species
Built to gift — no tackle box required
Built for discovery, not just delivery
Value takeaway
MTB is the easiest box to start with
Lowest starting price in this lineup, clear plan tiers, and enough flexibility for beginners, gift buyers, and anglers who want to discover more than one brand.
See MTB plans →The #1 tackle subscription
Select Your Plan
Choose between Regular, Pro, or Elite based on how much tackle you want, then select your species & duration.
Step 1 · Pick your level
Step 2 · Pick your species
Step 3 · Pick your plan duration
Free shipping on every multi-month plan!
Pause, cancel or change species anytime
FAQs
Still comparing? Start here
Real answers for anglers weighing their options.
What if I only fish bass?
What if I really love Googan or 6th Sense?
What if I want the most premium box?
I'm new to tackle subscriptions. Where should I start?
Can I try MTB before I subscribe?
Last Cast
Ready for the box that does more?
Curated tackle, flexible plans, broader discovery, starting at $19.99/mo.
Start with MTB →