Need help choosing?

Not sure which box? We got you

Tell us how you fish and we'll point you to the right box based on your target species and fishery.

Find my box →

Compare Fishing Subscription Boxes Before You Buy

Some boxes are built for bass-only anglers. Some are built for fans of one brand. Some cost a small boat payment.

MTB is built for anglers of all abilities: affordable, flexible, giftable & easy-to-start.

Start with MTB →See the comparison
$19.99/mo

to start

5 species

fish what you chase

Gift-ready

no tackle box needed

Flexible

pause or cancel anytime

Need help choosing?

Tell us how you fish and we'll point you to the right box based on your target species and fishery.

A Comparison of Price, Ratings, & Features

Everything you need to size up the field before you pick. No spin — just the facts, side by side.

Brand Rating Boxes sold / subs Price Items Brand variety Species Education Gift fit Best for
MTBBest all-around 3.8★ Trustpilot 10M+ boxes sold $19.99+ 4 – 10 Multi-brand Multi-species Yes Strong Most anglers
MONSTERBASS 2.6★ Trustpilot Thousands of anglers $28.95+ 6 – 7+ Multi-brand Bass Guidebook Good Bass anglers
Googan 5★ site display Not listed $34.99 6 – 8 Googan only Bass-style Limited Good Googan fans
Lucky 2.8★ Trustpilot 50K+ subscribers Varies 7 – 14 Multi-brand Multi-species Strong Good Tutorials
FishVault Not listed Not listed $160 Premium Mixed gear Bass / gear Limited Premium High budget
6th Sense 5★ product page Not listed Mid-tier 6th Sense 6th Sense only Bass-style Limited Fans Brand loyalists

Lowest start

MTB at $19.99+

Most premium

FishVault at $160

Rating sources vary by brand. Trustpilot ratings are company-level public reviews; Googan and 6th Sense show ratings on product or brand pages; FishVault does not list a clear star rating on its own site.

Best all-around pick

Mystery Tackle Box

✓

Lowest entry price among the mainstream options

✓

Clear Regular, Pro, and Elite plan ladder

✓

Bass, Panfish & Trout, Inshore Salt, Walleye & Multi-Species

✓

Built to gift — no tackle box required

✓

Built for discovery, not just delivery

Value takeaway

MTB is the easiest box to start with

Lowest starting price in this lineup, clear plan tiers, and enough flexibility for beginners, gift buyers, and anglers who want to discover more than one brand.

See MTB plans →

MTB plans

Pick your box, then pick your plan

Elite, Pro, or Regular — based on how much tackle and value you want showing up each month.

Step 1 · Pick your level

Step 2 · Pick your species

Step 3 · Pick your plan duration

Free shipping on every multi-month plan!

Pause, cancel or change species anytime

FAQs

Still comparing? Start here

Real answers for anglers weighing their options.

What if I only fish bass?
If bass is your whole world, a bass-only box like MONSTERBASS can be a solid fit. Want flexibility, more species, and a lower way in? That's where MTB shines.
What if I already love Googan or 6th Sense?
Love a single brand? A single-brand box makes sense. But if you want to discover new lure makers, styles, and techniques, MTB is built for the hunt.
What if I want the most premium box?
FishVault is the premium, high-budget pick. MTB wins for most folks — easier to start, easier to gift, and a lot less to lose month to month.
New to tackle subscriptions?
Start with MTB. Lowest starting price here, clear plans, and enough flexibility to learn what you actually like before you spend more.
Can I try MTB before I subscribe?
You bet. Start on Regular and cancel anytime. We've also got one-time products to sample MTB with no auto-rebill.

Final cast

Ready for the box that does more?

Curated tackle, flexible plans, broader discovery — starting at $19.99/mo.

Start with MTB →
Start with Mystery Tackle Box →